2018年8月2日星期四
SPM vs UEC - why this debate makes young people laugh
摘自《 Malaysiakini 》【读者来函】
LETTER | I was texting my sixteen-year-old cousin Hannah today, and I asked her how school was (what an “aunty question”). Her response was “Meh” and I’m very hip so I know that “Meh” today is the “Ugh, whatever, I don’t care” from my days in Form 4, just over ten years ago.
When I probed a little, Hannah gave me a deeper insight into what her beef with school was - She is in the Arts stream, Arts subjects like Economics and Accounting aren't taught in English and she’s definitely going to do A-levels so what’s the point of learning it in Malay (and why are only Sciences taught in English?)
Her interest in performing and creative arts is looked down upon by students and teachers and she’s just studying to get by. She would probably do best in an international school, I think, but I can’t tell her that now that she’s so close to the finish line (and honestly, she’s smart enough to know that already). But listening to Hannah now, I feel infinitely sad. Ten years later, and the national curriculum is still a joke.
I remember the first time that thought crossed through my mind: SPM is a joke. It was during a Moral Studies lesson. Do Malay people actually know what goes on in Moral class? Basically, we sit in a classroom and talk about the meanings of different moral values (there are 36 moral values that exist in this world. Well done, Ministry of Education for solving humanity’s greatest conundrum!)
This is by no means an intellectual conversation. Take Keadilan. Keadilan has a very specific meaning: “Tindakan dan keputusan yang tidak berat sebelah”. Change a word and you’re wrong. Use an example that’s not a model example and you’re wrong again. For two years of our lives, we’re made to waste hours of our lives memorising this stuff and what for? Honestly, ten years later, what was that for? And kids are still learning that now? And it’s still an SPM subject? What a joke.
Another time I found SPM both hilariously and hideously ridiculous was when it came to the SPM grading system. I rarely scored over 40 in my Add Maths exams the whole time I took the subject in school and was always in tears when I got my paper and it was a fail again. As SPM approached my (very nice) the Add Maths teacher told me conspiratorially “Don’t worry - you won’t fail at SPM.”
I had no idea what she meant and after sitting for the actual paper, came out of it thinking of the great shame I would bring upon my family being the first to fail a subject at SPM. And then on SPM results day, lo and behold, a C! I obtained a C! (C: credit)For the first time ever. At SPM, supposedly one of the biggest academic challenges the national curriculum could throw at me. I was awash with relief but also started to feel quite disdainful of this untruthful piece of paper that wrongly reflected to the world that I was an Add Maths-passer. How do you take pride in achievements in an education system that it so obviously shambolic?
I don’t know much about the UEC curriculum. But I do have a colleague who took the UEC, and he explained some of its strengths to me; he loved getting to study world history and Chinese history as well as Malaysian history. He felt sufficiently prepared for the university in terms of his proficiency in Science and Maths, although not in terms of language and multicultural skills. He appreciated the strict discipline of his school system and felt that his teachers pushed him because they cared.
There were definitely flaws in the system, he admitted, but overall he found his time at school challenging and interesting. Oh, and he took SPM just in case he needed it and thought it was quite a joke too.
Young people suffer for the sins of the old. I am one of the lucky ones, who had an array of options after SPM (despite not being prepared for any of them because most Social Science degrees require an ability to think critically, a quality that neither SPM nor UEC cultivates).
I can’t help but worry for future generations because a good education in Malaysia, whether it’s primary, secondary or tertiary, international, private or independent, is no longer free (and private education is inevitable, if unintentionally, divisive in terms of class and ethnicity). While old men squabble like children about the dangers of being multilingual, multiracial, multi-religious as though the country has been any other way for the last one hundred years, I wonder - have any of these old guys in power thought about providing a solution for the national curriculum that is an improvement for all Malaysians to last us for the next one hundred years?
For the record, I don’t think my long-imagined solution is unrealistic: strip the debate around education of race, religion and propaganda and revise the current curriculum to be more inclusive, current, truthful and challenging, remove time-wasting subjects (unless anyone has actually found a use for the 36 moral values?) and give students a wider range of options that will actually help them pursue their ambitions, rather than wait until they’ve left school to discover them.
Hannah is the last of our family to go to a national school. Everyone else sends their kids to international schools now, and I wonder how they afford it, but at the same time I know that if I had kids, I would want to give them the best too - and to me, international schools are clearly the better option if you have the money.
My colleague who went to a UEC school tells me that the only way he would send his kid to an SMK is if the quality became comparable to UEC, and this is regardless of whether the government recognises the UEC or not. He and I often laugh about whether we would rather save up for a house or a child. What a joke …
订阅:
博文评论 (Atom)
其他文章
7日最高点击率博文
-
毕业多年的朋友小飞问: 『 其实我有点忘了,当年我们统考成绩里的 C 到底是 Credit 还是 Pass ?』 我回问:『 那你印象中认为呢?』 小飞不确定说: 『 嗯.... 我觉得应该是Credit,因为SPM 成绩中 Grade C 也算是...
-
小编:三年前已經告诉大家了,但还是有很多人要跳火坑。 花2万深造却得假文凭 ◆ 百人控诉补习中心集团诈骗2000万(星洲日报 2019-07-27) 逾百名补习中心负责人和教职员报警申诉付费报读课程却拿到假文凭。前排中为游佳豪 (...
-
最近一些名校因招生问题,一时闹得沸沸扬扬。一些华文媒体把这些名校叫“控制学校”。原来它翻译自英文的control schools,其实他们误以为英文的control只有一个意义:控制,殊不知control还可翻译成“管制”。 “管制”指强制性地管理,例如管制交...
-
“堂号”是家族门户的统称,在中华姓氏中也占据着很高的地位。堂号有三个鲜明的特征:训诫后人将祖业发扬光大;彰显家族宗亲特点;弘扬祖先丰功伟绩。因为中国人的堂号有深厚的历史文化和实际意义,所以每当人们谈论到和自己同堂号、同堂号名人祖先时,总是流露出一些自豪的情感。那怎么才能通过...
-
作者 董教总华文独中工委会统一课程委员会 每本定价 东马 RM23.10 西马 RM21.00 ISBN 9789831694299 出版日期 2018年8月第1版 尺寸 26cm X 18.5cm 页数 170 ...
-
由董教总华文独中工委会统一课程委员会编纂的第四版独中初中一上、下册华文课本已经出版,并于2020年启用。新编初中华文课本配有教师手册和作业簿,將逐年取代现行独中初中华文教材。 第三版(初一至初三共6册) 🔶 2005~2019(2004年三所学校使用试教本,20...
-
小编: 当STPM和大学预科班考试系统同时制造许多满分的成绩,而现有国立大学的重要科系又无法提供足够学额时,这两种同时存在的畸形考试制度注定是彻底失败的。 在所有满分成绩的学生里,也许考试得 80分(可能更低,天知道!)是Gred A,100分也是Gred A,然后换算成 ...
-
小编: 每当我听到那些团体宣传什么生命密码、宇宙能量、天人感应 、心灵法则、颠覆科学、治愈百病之类的讲座、书籍或视频,我都会特别提高警惕。学校与家长也必须格外小心,避免孩子过早接触这些似是而非的论说。 (吉隆坡18日讯)一名家长林太太投诉,一个自称“...
-
问:马来西亚地区中学生如何申请到台湾读大学? 答:马来西亚学生可以两种身份赴台升学。 1. 外国学生身份 :以外国学生身份需自行向各大学院校申请,入学的条件、方式与管道皆须自行与各校联系。 2. 侨生身份 :依据现行马来西亚区适用简章申请资格须符合: (1)取得侨居地长...
标签
独中
(1384)
大马教育
(1076)
大马政治
(853)
大马华小
(519)
独中征聘启事
(483)
董总
(446)
承认统考
(363)
独中教育
(362)
大学教育
(291)
独中统考
(197)
华文教育
(180)
中国教育
(174)
独中教师
(139)
台湾教育
(131)
奖学金
(100)
外国教育
(88)
好文章
(76)
中文
(72)
中华文化
(64)
华文教育历史
(58)
奖助学金
(54)
中學教育
(52)
独中文凭
(51)
教育
(47)
独中课程
(46)
马来西亚
(41)
SPM
(39)
校长
(36)
小學教育
(33)
视频
(31)
数学
(30)
時事
(28)
假学历
(25)
新加坡
(24)
爪夷文
(21)
历史
(19)
征聘启事
(19)
农历新年
(16)
中国
(14)
独中数据
(14)
历史,承认统考
(12)
独中,独中教育
(11)
独中,
(10)
独中,台湾教育
(10)
親子教育
(9)
读者来函
(9)
Jokes
(8)
历史,
(8)
英语
(8)
科学
(7)
大专贷学金
(6)
历史,中国
(5)
文学
(5)
独中,中国
(5)
大马历史
(4)
投票成绩
(4)
马来文
(4)
IGCSE
(3)
华社
(3)
拉曼
(3)
漫画
(3)
独中校友
(3)
数据
(2)
科普
(1)
经济
(1)
没有评论:
发表评论